Home / Resources / How to spot an SEO cowboy

How to spot an SEO cowboy

The SEO industry has plenty of good people, and a few who give it a bad name. Here is how to tell the difference.

The warning signs

  • Guaranteed rankings. Nobody controls Google. A guarantee is either a lie or a sign they target searches nobody uses.
  • Secret methods. Good providers explain what they do and why. If it is a black box, be careful.
  • Unsolicited emails and calls. Messages claiming your site has problems and offering to fix them are usually mass-produced. In my opinion, an SEO business that has to cold call you is unlikely to be good at SEO. Good providers tend to be busy through referrals and reputation.
  • Bulk or cheap links. Buying links or joining link networks can lead to penalties that are hard to remove.
  • Long contracts with no exit. A confident provider does not need to trap you.
  • Reports full of vanity metrics. Impressions and rankings without enquiries or sales tell you little.
  • No access to your own accounts. You should own your analytics, Search Console and website.
  • Pressure to decide quickly. Real expertise does not need a countdown.

What good looks like

A good provider asks about your business before talking about SEO. They explain the plan in plain language, tell you what is uncertain, and report on things that matter to you. They are happy for you to speak to a developer or another professional about their advice, and they say no when your business is not a good fit.

How to check

  • Search for the business and the people behind it. Look for a real person, a real history and real reviews.
  • Ask for a clear scope in writing.
  • Check that you will own all accounts and data.
  • Ask what they would do in the first three months, and why.
  • Ask for a second opinion from someone independent if you are unsure. I am happy to review a proposal you have received.

If you have been burned before

I understand why you would be wary. So rather than asking you to simply trust me, I can give you a roadmap: the actions I will carry out, why each one matters and what impact it could have.

Where it suits, we can agree a simple structure. I carry out the agreed work. Then there is a gap, for example three months, with no further charge, so the work has time to take effect and you can see what good SEO looks like. After that, I review the results with you, and you decide whether to carry on. That way you are never paying for ongoing work without seeing it working.

A promise from me

I will tell you what I will do, what I will not do and what I cannot know. I will not guarantee results. I will tell you if I think you are better off spending your money elsewhere. If you would like a second opinion on a proposal, send it over.

Questions

What if I have already worked with a poor provider?

It is common, and often fixable. I can review what was done, repair any damage and put a plan in place.

Is it a red flag if someone will not share clients?

Not always, as clients may be confidential. But they should be able to explain their work and describe results in similar situations.

Want to talk about your search results?

Email me a few lines about your business and website. I will tell you honestly whether SEO is likely to be worth it for you right now.